3842 Sunrise Highway
Seaford, NY 11783
(516) 826-5200
  • Menu
  • Gallery
  • Contact Us
  • Order Online
  • Coupons
  • Gift Cards
  • Catering
  • Employment
Download the NEW Mario's Pizzeria Mobile App!

If you’re in Oyster Bay and looking for a good slice, you won’t go wrong with Mario’s.
I love this place. It’s always clean and the people are always so polite and friendly.
You cannot go wrong eating pizza here!
The best pizza hands down anywhere!  I’ve been coming here for 34 years.
Awesome selection and great quality food!!
I have lived in Plainview for the past six years and this is by far my favorite place in the town.
Really love to visit this place when I’m in Long Island. Their Buffalo Chicken pie is the best I’ve had
We order from them at least once per week. The food always arrives hot, fresh, and on time!
If you live in Syosset, there is no doubt that you frequent Mario’s Pizza. Mario’s has been in Syosset for probably over 40 years and is an institution.
It’s the pizza of my youth! Clean areas to sit and eat, and really friendly guys behind the counter!

© 2021 Mario's Pizzeria

REVIEWS

Web Design Agency